I have a soft top with frame for a 2004-2006 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited (LJ). The top does not leak and is functional. I used it as a trail top so it's not in mint condition. There is a tear on the driver side and a small hole by the header. The side windows have scuffing and are foggy from tree branches and etc. No holes though. The rear window is clear but the zipper has some issues. It is difficult to zip on and off in two spots. Hasn't been an issue for me as I never take it off and roll it up with I put the top down. Replacing the rear window will fix the issue since it's on the window that the zipper teeth have some issues.