I just installed the sailcloth Bestop and it's ok. I really don't see or hear the fuss, but I also installed the headliner as an option and it seems to help maintain better insulation. Now it really doesn't get all that cold here in south Louisiana, but the heat is a test all together. I will add the I am not impressed with the "Bestop" products. The quality is average, fit is marginal, and overall not worth the high cost. However, I have not compared other manufactures so this may be the norm. All that said, I do prefer the soft top for it's simplicity.