I like my soft top but I would have anything else than my hard top for winter (I know not a problem for you).
But you're asking for quietness. I found that when I switched to my hard top a month ago, that it was being like into a different Jeep, a lot more quiet (I have the regular, not premium), like night and day.
But my soft will be back in spring. I like it, it's like having 2 different Jeeps along the year.