You will most likely get as many opinions to that question as there are answers to the Shoe Size someone wears......
With that thought in mind, here's my opinion → I run the Rampage Frameless Soft Top, in the Sail Cloth version on my 2000 tj. I've run it now for a little over two years, both with, and without the Windows, as well as completely TopLess. It's had a lot of on and off activity. IT STILL HOLDS SHAPE, AND DOESN'T SAG. In the Winter around here, it has had as much as 8 to 10 inches of Snow resting on it. I'm pleased with the Top, as well as with it's functionality. I have heard others hate the Top, and have also read some nasty reviews on it. But also great reviews as well.
Here's a shot or two taken about a week or two ago with the Top, in both modes.
Choices .... I know can sometimes be OVERWHELMING... ► so have some
relax, maybe a Beer or two, and it will all of a sudden come to you as to what you want to do.