I had a Bestop on my first TJ and loved it.
My latest edition came with a Rugged Ridge.
To be nice, just remember, you get what you pay for. There is nothing "wrong" with my RR top--it just didn't have as much thought put into it when it was constructed. If I was faced with that decision, it would be Bestop -- NO QUESTIONS ASKED.
When this one wears out, I will replace it with a Bestop.