Have you looked at Classic Enterprises?
Go to: classicent.com
They have a good selection of replacement panels made in USA and they seem to be high quality. They have panels with the Jeep logo on the side (they say they have a license from Chrysler to make these).
The prices are pretty high, but I think it may be worth using a few of these - I am doing a major rebuild of a CJ-7 and will be replacing nearly everything from the "Jeep" on back.
My only problem with these folks is that they don't offer rear quarter panels - I will have to get them from Quadratec or 4WD, I guess. By the way - anybody have a preference between these two places (as far as body panels go), or a comment on the quality of those panels?
(My FIRST post on Wrangler Forum!