At most, you've got a 3.73 gearing, and that'll be a dog without a regearing. (Or a supercharger . . .
) More likely though you've got 3.21 gearing, which will be even doggier. Here's a chart that'll help point the way for appropriate gearing: (Tire & Gear Ratio Chart at Morris 4x4 Center
There's other mods you would also want to consider for 35s. For example, your front axle should probably be reinforced if you're going to do any serious offroading.
Welcome to the forum! Stop by the JK section and say "Hi"!