Going off looks alone I'd wager the dura's still clean out better. Not as much void in those sidewall lugs, would also explain why they're quieter.
Poverty/College Budget 2004 TJ BB, 1.25" BL, MML, JK shocks, 31x10.5 AT2's
If it can't be fixed with squats or fish oil...your probably gonna die (u aware?)
Amp is getting power but my sub isn't working. PM me to help!