You will NEVER go wrong with Tirerack. Call and check availability- their website's never lied to me in literally hundreds of orders for customers and myself. Their selection is dang good, customer service is top notch, and being able to read THOUSANDS of reviews on hundreds of different tires is awesome.
If you know a guy at a local spot, you MAY be able to save a couple bucks on shipping if you're getting bigger tires/wheels, but not much.
Also, delivery from Delaware gets to me (I'm across the river in Dutchess County) literally the next business day 99% of the time, which rocks. No patiently waiting for me! HAH