ok, here's something bad about them (Baja Claws, xterrain), ... they don't work on sidehills. All tires with that Chevron style tread, including the Geolander MT Plus, don't have any lateral grip to speak of. I've had Baja Claws before, and they pull good in a straight line, especially in sand. Don't try to drive on a steep sidehill road that is right above a barb wire fence if there is snow on the ground (ask me how I know).
Of the tires I've used in the last two to three years ...
I think the Goodyear MT/R w/K is a very good tire, perhaps one of the best for all around off road use. On road ride quality is not so good though, hard to balance, and they wear quickly.
Pro Comp Extreme MTs are very good all around tires. Their tread pattern is almost like an AT tire, so it is quiet on road and rides good, but the tread spacing is real wide and the tread lugs are real deep, so it still works like an MT off road. They seem to have more grip in most places than other tires do. The tread pattern makes them look like an implement tire though (like something that should be on a big self propelled swather, or combine).
Toyo Open Country MT tires are very good performing tires, and are near bullet proof. You can't hurt them and they wear for a long time. Their tread lugs are so big and soft that they are a bit squirmy feeling on the highway until they have 5000 miles on them, then they drive much better.
Mickey Thompson Baja MTZ tires work exceptionally well off road. They are more expensive than almost any other tire though, and over priced in my opinion.
Dick Cepek FC II tires have exeptionally good street manners, especially on wet or snowy roads. As with any AT tire, the tread spaces are too close together to grip all that well off road. Hard to stay on your line through a tough obstacle with these tires.
2014 Wrangler Sport: Teraflex/Synergy 3" suspension lift, Fox 2.0 reservoir shocks, Tom Wood 1350 driveshafts, Dynatrac ProRock 60s w/ 4.56 gears and Eaton electric lockers, Warn front locking hubs, Currie Anti-rock front swaybar, Fox ATS, 37" Toyo MTs on 17x8.5 Fuel Anza's, Poison Spyder bumpers and rocker guards, Warn M8000s winch, Teraflex tailgate hinge & spare tire carrier, Mopar head liner