I really like most of the more "out there" Jeep colors. When I was younger, and really until I started paying close attention to JKs because I wanted one, I always pictured a yellow TJ or YJ in my mind when I thought of a Jeep. I guess I'd seen many yellow topless Jeeps with half doors or doorless in the summer, so I'd associated Jeeps with "crazier" colors, if you will (and I don't mean crazy or out there in a bad way at all). So I really like those more vibrant and bold colors, like the oranges, yellows, the bright greens, bright blues, etc.
But my Jeep is my DD. If I had a regular car and I could get a Jeep as a weekend, fun car, I would totally get it in a "cool" color. But for everyday, I agree, I think a colorful one would be too much for me personally.
I got mine used, and went for the best deal, so I didn't have too much control over the color. All I knew was I didn't want green, because my previous car was green and I didn't get to pick it because it was my first car, and I was not a fan of the green. It's funny, because when I found my used Jeep online at a BMW dealer in NW Jersey (it was a trade-in), the listing had it as "green" but the pics were all silver, so we called and the first thing I said was, "if it's green and you have the wrong pictures, I don't even want to come look at it."
But the listing was wrong, it was silver.
But when I was looking, I almost got a red one, actually, and I looked at and considered many colors. Had I bought new or had more of a choice, rather than trying to find the best deal with what exactly I wanted, I would have probably gone with an all white Sahara or an Anvil one but new and even used Saharas are a lot of money, and I don't regret my choice at all given the deal I got - on top of many other cool things for the money, mine came with both tops. No regrets, but in the future if I get another Jeep, I will probably pick a less "boring" color. I love seeing each year's new colors!