It's really just a personal preference call on your part IMO.
Here's my '13 JKUR lifted, with 155 miles on the clock, sitting at the Discount Tire parking lot getting ready for some 35s. I immediately lifted it in my garage with a Rock Krawler 2.5" Max Travel Pro kit. I netted closer to 3.25" of lift though, so mine will appear higher than what you're estimating.
I don't like the look at all, but that's just me. Plenty of people could run it that way and be happy. Just decide if it works for you.
And to make the wait for new wheels and tires really, really hard:
It still looks like there's a ton of room under the flares, because their is, but the bigger tires and wider stance really balance thing out quite nicely IMO. The flat flares really opened things up for me.