The common advice is 4.56's for 33's and 4.88's for 35's. However, if it was me and it was my daily driver, I would go one step numerically lower. In other words, I would stick with 4.56's. Especially considering it is a JK capable of reasonably high speeds and a daily driver. Also, you may want to scale back to 33's at some point.
Edit: I'm sorry, I assumed we were talking about a manual trans. What do you have?