I loved the idea of the 4 door and waited for them to come out. But once here I didn't like the overall package. I like the rear seat. I like the extra space when the rear seat is folded forward. But I don't like the look. For me, a wrangler is 2 door.
My daughter (15) even said when I went out to buy my new 2008 - "If you come home with a 4 door Wrangler, I will disown you". She, of course, was kidding. But when I got to the lot (after not buying a year ago) I couldn't see me on trails with the longer Wrangler. Just half-defeats the purpose of a compact all-trail vehicle.
Plus I don't put my wife in the back so she doesn't worry about the rear-seat access.