Anything that is made of 3/16th or 1/4 steel plate and is reinforced correctly will do the job.
The thing about thin bumpers are for them to fold under stress thus making all the impact power go into the steel and into nothing else especially you. With a super strong bumper it will transfer to you and most likely your frame if it is a really good hit.
But why plan a bumper around a fender bender, unless they happen to you often? lol. I ripped the stock bumper off of my Jeep in a recovery situation, but haven't added one back. It's good for departure angles, it looks just like the rear bumper from Rokmen. Yes it wouldn't be good for a fender bender but if it happens it happens. I deal with my departure angle more then I do fender benders
But it is always good to be safe!