Have you checked scrap yards? There is a Jeep "graveyard" south of me but might be pricey to ship? IDK PM me if you want a phone number.
About 6 months after I got my Jeep was rear ended-went to the Jeep graveyard-and they had the tailgate, bumper, and milk jugs, taillight R side and hinges waiting for me an hour after I called. Even the "right" color.
I just removed bad parts and put on good. Only $300 for everything. Yes I took insurance money and ran.