Hey, awesome! I just traded my Dodge Dakota in yesterday on a Wrangler...LOL
The only recommendation I could offer is personally I would look for a Jeep with the 4.0L engine in it...gas mileage will suffer a little bit, but I have driven both and the 4.0L has so much more get up and go. My buddy who sold me this Jeep used to own one with the 2.5L and when he brought mine back to the lot, he said, "Dang dude! This thing drives SO much better than my Jeep did!"
Just my opinion...we won't hate you if you choose the 4 cylinder.