I have no experience with any of them but my padding is faded and If I had to pick one I would pick bestop because they manufacture some of the oem fabric pieces for the jeep (soft top) and are known to have good quality so I would trust them.
Curious to see anyones input. Mine are ragged and faded but dont know which will fit best
My father in law dyed his faded padding. Not sure what he used
__________________ My Toys
2003 RED Jeep Wrangler X - Can't stop adding stuff and updating.
2014 White Jeep Liberty Sport
2011 Carbon Black GMC Yukon Denali
2007 Black GMC Sierra 2500HD 4x4 Duramax/Allison
2007 Keystone Laredo 284BHS TT
I've just ordered a full set of Rugged Ridge Black Denim Rollbar covers and will be happy to write up a bit of a review when I get and install them.
Also have ordered a full Bikini top, A Cargo cover for the back and a new Bedrug Carpet and heat shield.
I've had 6 jeeps and the roll bar pads have always been ragged and faded after a few years... I've used all the brand and it is a toss up on best quality and fit..But this jeep I tried a little trick... I washed my outer covers in the dishwasher... Then I went and bought some black dye ( like clothing dye at Walmart) and soaked them overnight in the solution ( cheap totes work well).. Used double the recommended amount of dye... Rinsed them out the next day and dried them.. Installed after lubricating the zippers and looks awesome... And it saved a ton of hard earned coin..
Forgot the brand but I bought some off another member last yr that all the pieces velcro over the roll bar except the ones above the doors(wtf?) Call me lazy but I did not even want to dismount the roll bar to slide them over so I painted my faded spice color padding with black fabric rattlecan paint to match. Worked out great.