I bought the neoprene from Quadratech and the red is fading to pink on the drivers side after two years. The jeep is out of the elements 4 out of 7 days, and every night. I did hit them with a conditioner to protect them.
I'm goiing to replace them with Bestops replacements based on comments from some folks that have had both.
As far as comfort the neo's provided extra support and felt great.
Not too sure a/b the floor mats, but I have Okole Wet seat covers. They are performing great having been on the jeep for 4 yrs. No fading at all. They are also padded and very comfortable. Great buy by the previous owner!
'01 Wrangler Se 2.5L 4 Banger Yellow, Bone stock except the new full safari/windjammer/tonneau