Two years ago I sold my '01 Wrangler stock SE (2.5L engine) with 86,000 miles on it. At the time the NADA guide the dealers use was quoting nearly $12,000 in spite of the mileage which surprised me. I received more calls on it than I could have ever imagined. Sold it within the week. Bottom line - these guys have given you solid advice; $10,000 is a good price.