I put the rampage bowless top on my YJ, and its ok, but not great.... The quality is ok, but once again, not great. I'm pretty sure that installing this top on a YJ is less cumbersome than with a factory soft top and its hardware. That being said, there is NO way would I get rid of the factory style TJ top on my TJ. The stock TJ framework and top is sooo much easier to install and the overall quality and fitment cant be beat. For a cheapo top, I guess a bowless top would be ok on the TJ.... but I prefer the stock top/hardware.