I feel your pain. I deleted the previous owners 3" body lift.
I would recommend going with 1.25" body lift and 2" spring spacers. The nice thing about a 1.25" BL is it allows for aftermarket tucked gas tank skids, and even a tummy tuck. That is my set up w 33x12.5x15s. I have also added the Savvy Under Armor (w TC lift).
Don't forget to increase your bump stops to match the spring spacer.
2003 TJ Rubicon 5-speed 33x12.50x15 DuraTracs on Soft 8s, JKS 1.25" BL, rear UCAs & TBs, 2"BB front, Anti-rock/Addco f/r sway bars, Black Magic brakes, OME Shocks/rear springs, MCE 6" flatties, BDO Rockers, and Savvy Under-Armor TT & GTS!
02 Z28 Hardtop LS1/T56 SOLD-reason for screen name 1984 C4 Corvette LS1/T56 swap in progresss
"Sheeps don't mod Jeeps."