Thanks for the input!
This is what I did and it works!
The first position I tried made my speedometer go in reverse! Made me feel like I was driving on the wrong side of the road in Europe or something.
I then removed the rubber o-ring temporarily to get a good feel when inserting it. I put it in and starting turning. Right off the bat one of the four positions was not going to work. Did that a few times and got an idea of where it should go. Happened to be in the same position before the SYE.
I was joking about it going in reverse!