Okay, so my informal poll about the stickers on my TJ pretty much said that my wife was right and I was wrong.
Thanks to all of you who participated for your candid (though brutal) opinions.
In response, I have removed all but a few stickers. I kept one on just to cover up the 'Hidden Hitch' decal which I will either remove or, be lazy and just spray paint over it. I held my ground on my "Kiss me I'm Irish" sticker because, you just never know, one day some cute red-haired Irish lass might just take me up on it.
Of course, there was the question...what do I do with my stickers? I think I found a way to keep them out of sight and still salvage my wounded pride by keeping them on the tailgate (see picture 3).
Thanks again for all of your smart-assed....ooops...I mean candid responses!
Before and After Pics