don't have personal experience with either, but everything i've read praises both highly and it pretty much comes down to personal preference. both with suit your needs very well and are comparable to each other. i think the mt's are supposed to have a little better tread life, but driving habits, maintence, etc all have an effect on that . some say mtr's are better, other say mt's are the way to go. i'd go with mt's if it were me, just because of my experience with bfg at's.