Nope, it won't fit. The CJ 5 is 10 inches shorter in the body and the pre-76 models have a wider windshield at the top. Oh... and the mounting flange for the tops around the edge of the body are different.
2013 JKU Rubi, Minor Mods: Sheldon
1974 CJ-6, 1-tons, 40's, 401 V-8, TH400, and lots of stuff: Panthro