Thanks guys. I got all pieces bare metal and had them powder coated myself.
I got the rear corner guards and inner fenders and inner fender wells powder coated with a black undercoat and a green flake overcoat to simulate, but not quite match the Shale Green Pearlcoat body color. I had the outer fender flares and rocker guards powder coated a satin black to match the texture of the Warn bumpers.
I was going for a 'stock' coloring/pattern, with the functionality of the MetalCloaks.
Below is a direct pic of the rear corner guard, subtly powder coated in green flake.