America's tire is where I would go now, my first set of tires 33s were from there and had a great experience there customer service is top notch. I did however buy my 35s I have on now from sears auto. Smoking deal is the only reason why I bought the there (buddy of mine hooked me up), but they have to many issues balancing them to like going back. And 18months 0% financing.
95 YJ 5in lift w/35x12.5 MTR/k locked front and rear, Ford 8.8 swap, OBA, 2.5l low output