Originally Posted by Offroadtimmy
I fount a really nice 2011 JKU 19,500 miles 6 speed loaded w/ tow package for 25k.
That word lost me a game of "Words with Friends"
As to your question I would get the brand new one. Whats $5k when we are talking about a dealer warrante, possibly oil changes for life, etc. And if your planning on doing some off roading from what I've read Auto is the way to go.
Too much going on to worry about shifting properly. Sadly I use my jeep as a weekend toy, mall crawling mostly. But I love the stick as my DD is auto. It really adds to the sense of enjoyment for me.
Just my .02