Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   JK General Discussion Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/)
-   -   Manual or Automatic transmission (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/manual-or-automatic-transmission-106663.html)

SRPs 2012 08-09-2011 11:35 AM

Manual or Automatic transmission
 
I know there are pros and cons for getting either a manual transmission or automatic transmission. How long does it take to get use to shifting gears on the wrangler? What are some pros and cons of getting either transmission?
I purchased a manual because of the cost savings and better control over the vehicle in the winter. I can see where an automatic could be pretty good too. Your thoughts?

Mac2411 08-09-2011 11:51 AM

It is mostly a matter of personal preference. There are many, many threads covering this topic on these forums.

Arpd3 08-09-2011 02:38 PM

I prefer manual for many reasons you already described and I also want full control at all times.

6 speed trumps automatic for alot of reasons

but i guess how would you be able to sip your frappucino without automatic?

SA Wrangler Junkie 08-09-2011 02:55 PM

Don't know if this helps but over here the Auto seems a bit sluggish. I've recently traded my Auto for the Manual and love it!! Personal prefrence I agree.....

QueueCumber 08-09-2011 02:59 PM

Automatic if it is a 2012. Though I guess I would still get auto even on other models. I've had so many clutch systems over the years in all kinds of vehicles; I will never go back again...

On the 2012 models with the new engines I can still choose to put the car into manual by using the column shifter to choose the gears (On older models this is not an option though...). Using this setup I can manually choose the gear that the car is in without having to constantly push an antiquated clutch system in with my foot. I get the best of both worlds with that setup as far as I am concerned...

:firedevil:

jk'n 08-09-2011 07:23 PM

Since you already have purchased a standard and you are wondering how long it takes to get used to it, I'll start there. I went from an automatic caravan....cause they didn't have it in standard....that I drove for seven long years back to a standard in my jeep. It took me a year and a half to get totally back into a standard. I shift now like I never went to automatic. I also think it is easier to coordinate the feet on my Rubicon with 4.1 gears than it was on my Sahara with 3.73. I drove the Sahara for 8 months before Chrysler bought it back from me. The extra torque off of the stop makes things a little easier. All in all, I will never go back to an automatic unless something happens to one of my legs. But I don't drive standard for a living so I like driving one to get from point A to point B....especially through the woods!

JeeperJake 08-09-2011 08:35 PM

re: "I can still choose to put the car into manual by using the column shifter to choose the gears (On older models this is not an option though...)."

don't understand this comment.....even on an antique 08 JK I can choose my gear with the shift stick, or leave it in auto.

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 08:43 PM

:whistling: Are you saying that there are buttons on the steering wheels--


Quote:

Originally Posted by QueueCumber (Post 1454166)
Automatic if it is a 2012. Though I guess I would still get auto even on other models. I've had so many clutch systems over the years in all kinds of vehicles; I will never go back again...

On the 2012 models with the new engines I can still choose to put the car into manual by using the column shifter to choose the gears (On older models this is not an option though...). Using this setup I can manually choose the gear that the car is in without having to constantly push an antiquated clutch system in with my foot. I get the best of both worlds with that setup as far as I am concerned...

:firedevil:

For the auto shifting gears 1 thru 4--then O/D--along with the manual gearshift lever ????

:dance::rofl: JIMBO

ESP 08-09-2011 09:09 PM

:banghead:

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 09:14 PM

:whistling: Are you (smiley) saying that you understand exactly what he's saying ??


Quote:

Originally Posted by ESP123 (Post 1455486)
:banghead:

--JIMBO

ORNGCR8 08-09-2011 09:17 PM

A puppy just died.

ESP 08-09-2011 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JIMBOX (Post 1455507)
:whistling: Are you (smiley) saying that you understand exactly what he's saying??

http://www.wranglerforum.com/f19/man...ic-105052.html
http://www.wranglerforum.com/f33/man...on-106663.html
http://www.wranglerforum.com/f33/201...to-105835.html
http://www.wranglerforum.com/f33/aut...-me-98667.html
http://www.wranglerforum.com/f33/aut...ual-78127.html

:banghead:

JeeperJake 08-09-2011 09:32 PM

Are you (smiley) saying that you understand exactly what he's saying ??....are you talking to ME????

if so....maybe not
if not....still unsure of the issue.....

shift buttons on steering wheel? Like the 1957 Torque Flight Dodge????

or what?

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 09:32 PM

:whistling: Thanx ESP--


You won't have to worry about me asking anymore questions, EVER from you-

You're way to knowledgeable for the likes of me !!

-JIMBO

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 09:37 PM

:whistling: Well, he mentioned COLUMN SHIFTER to choose gears and the COLUMN is the STEERING column-


Quote:

Originally Posted by JeeperJake (Post 1455614)
Are you (smiley) saying that you understand exactly what he's saying ??....are you talking to ME????

if so....maybe not
if not....still unsure of the issue.....

shift buttons on steering wheel? Like the 1957 Torque Flight Dodge????

or what?

And he said, we didn't have that option on older models--

Suptoyou

:dance::rofl: JIMBO

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 09:41 PM

:rolleyes: Wait, I don't really care about this 2012 jeep, so just forget anything I asked aboutit--

No more querys about the new jeep--

Color me gone !!(about new jeep)

--JIMBO

ESP 08-09-2011 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JIMBOX (Post 1455615)
:whistling: Thanx ESP--




You won't have to worry about me asking anymore questions, EVER from you-

You're way to knowledgeable for the likes of me !!

-JIMBO

I know your a fan of my work.

JIMBOX 08-09-2011 09:58 PM

:rolleyes:--no more worries--


Quote:

Originally Posted by ESP123 (Post 1455720)
I know your a fan of my work.

-JIMBO

Eaglektd 08-09-2011 10:24 PM

manual all the way, automatics get too hot and burst into flames :firedevil:
then you don't have a jeep at all

QueueCumber 08-09-2011 10:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JeeperJake (Post 1455332)
re: "I can still choose to put the car into manual by using the column shifter to choose the gears (On older models this is not an option though...)."

don't understand this comment.....even on an antique 08 JK I can choose my gear with the shift stick, or leave it in auto.

Ah. I didn't know that you could do it on older models (the last time I had a Jeep Wrangler it was a manual in the 80s...). I guess I would choose auto no matter what then...

QueueCumber 08-09-2011 10:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JIMBOX (Post 1455372)
:whistling: Are you saying that there are buttons on the steering wheels--




For the auto shifting gears 1 thru 4--then O/D--along with the manual gearshift lever ????

:dance::rofl: JIMBO

I meant the shifter in between the two seats (manumatic shifter...).

DeanLinAZ 08-09-2011 10:48 PM

As the old Volkswagen Beetle ads used to say back in the 60's & 70's--
"After driving a Volkswagen a couple of blocks, shifting becomes automatic".

I've had and have both, they both work, get the one you like best.:D

ruggedCityJeep 08-09-2011 10:51 PM

Tastes great/Less filling.....

Every time an automatic changes gears, our National Debt increases by one billion.

jk wrangler fan 08-09-2011 11:11 PM

There's an old saying that goes something along the lines of "if you have to ask, you want an auto".

off a cough 08-09-2011 11:46 PM

On TJ Forums that I used to visit, this was the 2nd most posted question, behind only "how do I turn off my dome lights when the doors are off?"

FWIW I went from the NV3550 in the TJ Rubi (5spd manual) to the W5A580 (5spd auto) in a 4dr JK Rubi. I'll miss the manual transmission a bit, but the new auto is a smooth and precise enough gear box that I'll cope with it. I wouldn't get the previous 4spd auto in the JK based on reputation.

xj-boonie 08-10-2011 02:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by QueueCumber
Automatic if it is a 2012. Though I guess I would still get auto even on other models. I've had so many clutch systems over the years in all kinds of vehicles; I will never go back again...

On the 2012 models with the new engines I can still choose to put the car into manual by using the column shifter to choose the gears (On older models this is not an option though...). Using this setup I can manually choose the gear that the car is in without having to constantly push an antiquated clutch system in with my foot. I get the best of both worlds with that setup as far as I am concerned...

:firedevil:

An auto with the +/- to shift into a specific gear is in no way similar to a manual transmission. It is still a slow shifting, do what it wants thing. I'm just saying...

QueueCumber 08-10-2011 07:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xj-boonie (Post 1456181)
An auto with the +/- to shift into a specific gear is in no way similar to a manual transmission. It is still a slow shifting, do what it wants thing. I'm just saying...

Indeed, but it is good enough for the situations where I would ever need to use manual, such as particular low speed off-road situations. Likewise, the automatic will make my life more enjoyable for regular driving, especially in traffic and city driving with all of the stop and go. I get tired of using the clutch off and on in those situations for long stretches.

This isn't a supercar; I don't need it to up rev or down rev when shifting up or down in order to get the best lap times at the track. My sportscar does these things. The manumatic does enough for the situations in which I would want to shift the Jeep into a lower gear at slow speeds. The manumatic gives me all the control that I need over the gears. I don't need to drive a Jeep like a racecar in manual (heel to toe shift, ride the clutch, etc.) in any situations in which I would use it. Likewise, I gain a more comfortable drive for myself in 90% of my driving life.

xj-boonie 08-10-2011 10:29 AM

The thing I can't stand in all the autos I've ever driven is the pause between stepping on the gas and anything happening. It's frustrating when trying to make a turn in traffic or when passing. I don't heel/toe or any if that crap in my XJ, but I do like that it goes when I need it to, no wait fir the tranny to catch up to the engine.

QueueCumber 08-10-2011 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xj-boonie (Post 1456801)
The thing I can't stand in all the autos I've ever driven is the pause between stepping on the gas and anything happening. It's frustrating when trying to make a turn in traffic or when passing. I don't heel/toe or any if that crap in my XJ, but I do like that it goes when I need it to, no wait fir the tranny to catch up to the engine.

I've never had that happen when shifting a vehicle in manumatic mode. I have had it happen in automatic even in my GT-R, but never when using manumatic modes.

PTaylor 08-10-2011 11:14 AM

Own both!:thumb:

Auto's are great for standard travel, I love the auto on the floor. My first was a stick, loved it, but got tired of shifting. Got an auto, loved it, but missed the control over shifting. Got a stick, loved it, but again, there are times when shifting is a pain. got an auto, love it, but still miss that control.



I'll tell you one thing, drinking a "can" is a hell of a lot easier in an auto than a stick!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:35 PM.