Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   YJ Tech Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f218/)
-   -   auto or manual? (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f218/auto-or-manual-142180.html)

kbar 02-25-2012 02:04 PM

auto or manual?
 
Ok so I got a 2.5 YJ with and AX5, I know the AX5 is a POS, and so in the near future I am wanting to do a tranny swap. I love having a manual tranny, but I went out this weekend and almost burnt my clutch up....so kinda is making me ponder about getting an auto. I will probably be able to get my hands on an AX4(cherokee tranny if I am correct) or and AX15. I have read great reviews on both trannys, but trail wise, would I want an auto or manual?

CJPete 02-25-2012 02:23 PM

On the trail it's always better to have more control, and the manual allows that. The automatic is always moving forward in D, and you might not want that on more technical crawls.

VinceTj 02-25-2012 03:35 PM

burning the clutch is usually a 12 inchs problem more than a tranny problem

BT 02-25-2012 04:11 PM

Actually on the trail the Auto can be more advantageous. As said you're always going forward in drive (or the vehicle is at least attempting to) and This can prevent you from rolling backwards on a steep hill. Also an auto will let you switch gears almost instantaneously which can be helpful if you get hung up in some mud and need to back out quick to give it another go. I love a 5 speed on road but on the trail I love the auto.

cavediverjc 02-25-2012 05:20 PM

For hardcore rock crawling, the auto wins hands-down. All the competitive rigs run autos in them. For everything else, a manual is fine. My TJ was an auto and I LOVED it in the rocks. My YJ is a 5-speed and I haven't had a chance to take it offroad yet.

Irongrave 02-25-2012 05:30 PM

AX5s are cheep and you can do a few things to make them last. the 2.5 isnt going to blow one up. I have no issues with mine and I abuse my rig quite hard. an AX15 swap is a lot of work and money to get the part you need its not a simple swap. the AW4 while a great trans will suck the life out of a 2.5.

Jeep716 02-25-2012 05:46 PM

I've driven a few 2.5 autos and did not like them. The 2.5 is fine behind a five speed but really lags with a auto from my experience.

Jon70 02-25-2012 06:22 PM

Agree with Jeep716 he is right on.

Xpress 02-25-2012 08:13 PM

You would need to get yourself a VERY good automatic transmission (something with less than 5% power loss through the torque converter) to keep the ponies coming out of the 2.5. It's a great engine but automagics tend to suck power out of it.

The AX5 will be fine behind it. If it's still working fine, why fix it? You don't need an automatic for 90% of offroading anyways. Most rock krawlers use automatics because they often have to inch up steep rock faces, little bit at a time. But those are FAR from stock..

kbar 02-25-2012 09:17 PM

Well I can get a tranny for 50 bucks, why not.

CJPete 02-29-2012 12:37 PM

If you're getting it for $50, I'd tear it down and inspect everything before I install it. Usually if it's that cheap, it's for a reason.

Xpress 02-29-2012 01:08 PM

Yeah, it might be cheaper to just put a new clutch in if that's the reason why you're going to swap trannys.

ballistx 02-29-2012 01:53 PM

Fix the "Y"
 
Question is "Why did you just about burn your clutch out?". Were you in 4WD/low range/low gear?

I don't see any situation where it would make one iota of difference if you had a 5spd AX-5 or a 5spd AX-15 if you are burning clutches.

Typically the fix for burning a clutch is to get into a higher gear ratio. That means, typically, getting into a lower gear. There are 10 gear ratios available with each. And yes, the 2.5 WILL burn out a clutch if improperly operated.

PS, Why is a transmission that is recognized to work up to 300,000 miles a POS?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:35 AM.