Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   TJ General Discussion Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f282/)
-   -   Sad Axle News (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f282/sad-axle-news-202031.html)

Harris4627 11-27-2012 03:52 PM

Sad Axle News
 
I took my jeep to the local 4WP shop for some steering issues, and found out that i need a new front axle. :facepalm: So, I figure why not just do a complete dana 44 swap front and rear and upgrade to disc brakes in the rear, do a comp cut and stretch... :thumb: I have no clue where to even begin... The jeep is safe to drive in the mean time, and its my daily driver, so thats good news, but i'm completely lost. I have no idea what all is involved in doing this. I know that it will be a lot of work, and i'd like to get all the parts and get it done on a weekend, but i'm not sure what to buy... I've googled it and searched a bit on here and I can't really find a forum on these things in particular... Any help would be greatly appreciated. :Thanx:

UnlimitedLJ04 11-27-2012 03:56 PM

exactly why do you need a whole new front axle?

Dextreme 11-27-2012 04:00 PM

If the whole front axle is trashed (like bent axle tubes), I would simply get a bolt in replacement D30 (or D44). Then start worrying about all that other custom stuff that takes alot of time and planning to do correctly.

UnlimitedRubicon 11-27-2012 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dextreme (Post 3039513)
If the whole front axle is trashed (like bent axle tubes), I would simply get a bolt in replacement D30 (or D44).

^ this



Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
a complete dana 44 swap front and rear and upgrade to disc brakes in the rear, do a comp cut and stretch

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
I have no clue where to even begin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
I have no idea what all is involved in doing this.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
I know that it will be a lot of work

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
get it done on a weekend


:confused:

local15Rob 11-27-2012 05:21 PM

. I know that it will be a lot of work, and i'd like to get all the parts and get it done on a weekend

:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl:

Derp 11-27-2012 06:27 PM

You understand the dollar sign you just threw up right?? A weekend job....I just laughed. Good thing were not on pirate :rollseyes:

Jerry Bransford 11-27-2012 06:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3039487)
I took my jeep to the local 4WP shop for some steering issues, and found out that i need a new front axle.

What happened to it where you believe the entire axle must be replaced? Was it destroyed beyond salvaging it in something like an accident? Beyond major damage like that, it doesn't take much to rebuild an axle with new bearings or gears if nearly anything else is wrong.

Harris4627 11-28-2012 12:06 PM

Well, I'm just relaying the message that they (4WP) gave me. They said the tube was bent and it was trashing control arm bushings because the tow was jacked up or something. Bent C's maybe? I've owned jeeps my whole life and never had to deal with anything like this, so thats why I'm looking for advice. I don't really know whats all involved. I was thinking about just finding a dana 30, and upgrading to better axle shafts, and throwing a spartan locker in it, and then doing the same to the rear later. I guess my biggest concern was the stretch kit... That's more less what I'm confused about.

Harris4627 11-28-2012 12:09 PM

Good thing were not on pirate :rollseyes:[/QUOTE]

I don't know what pirate is... Another Forum?

Moabrubi 11-28-2012 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627 (Post 3043135)
Well, I'm just relaying the message that they (4WP) gave me. They said the tube was bent and it was trashing control arm bushings because the tow was jacked up or something. Bent C's maybe? I've owned jeeps my whole life and never had to deal with anything like this, so thats why I'm looking for advice. I don't really know whats all involved. I was thinking about just finding a dana 30, and upgrading to better axle shafts, and throwing a spartan locker in it, and then doing the same to the rear later. I guess my biggest concern was the stretch kit... That's more less what I'm confused about.

A stretch kit is more then just a weekend of work. If you really want to stretch big It takes weeks, even months to do it right. We are talking stretch tank (or fuel cell) redoing entire rear suspension, hacking the body to recenter wheel well, blah blah blah.

To be honest, if all you know of a stretch kit is that is moves the tire back then you shouldn't do one. I've considering stretching mine but it is just too much work, especially if you try to go for 100".

Pirate4x4 is a forum where the more "hardcore" guys go. Dana 60s, 14 bolts, 42s", custom suspension, 110" wheelbase guys. Really cool rigs to oogle over but not practical for me.

Dextreme 11-28-2012 12:35 PM

...

lynn 11-28-2012 12:49 PM

You really need to go back to the shop and talk to the management and the techs involved. Don't leave until they show you what is wrong, with demonstrations, measurements, etc. Don't leave until you fully understand the situation and all available options.

Since this is your DD, and because you do not have a solid understanding of the ramifications of an axle upgrade or frame stretch...
I heartily recommend that if necessary (assuming a repair is not feasible), you simply replace your current axle with a good, used bolt-in replacement exactly like the current one. That will put you back on the road quickly and most cost-effectively.

Then you can spend time doing research on the mods you think you want, and learning what is involved with each one...

Good luck!!

Harris4627 11-28-2012 01:12 PM

Thanks for the info guys I really do appreciate it. The more research I do the more I think I will jsut do a new axle with chromoly shafts and lockers. The stretch is something I really want to do, but it will definitely be in the future when I have a new daily driver, or in the summer when I can ride my motorcycle everyday while the work is being done. I plan on heading back to the shop tomorrow and getting some more explanation on whats exactly wrong. Any recommendations on axle shafts? I figured I'd run spartan lockers front and rear... But I'll take all the advice anyone wants to give. I'm not completely trusting when it comes to 4WP... I'm afraid they will try to just do whats best for them ($$$) than what is truly best for the jeep.

Derp 11-28-2012 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harris4627
Thanks for the info guys I really do appreciate it. The more research I do the more I think I will jsut do a new axle with chromoly shafts and lockers. The stretch is something I really want to do, but it will definitely be in the future when I have a new daily driver, or in the summer when I can ride my motorcycle everyday while the work is being done. I plan on heading back to the shop tomorrow and getting some more explanation on whats exactly wrong. Any recommendations on axle shafts? I figured I'd run spartan lockers front and rear... But I'll take all the advice anyone wants to give. I'm not completely trusting when it comes to 4WP... I'm afraid they will try to just do whats best for them ($$$) than what is truly best for the jeep.

I'd go Aussie up front and full case in the rear for lockers. Spartans are noisey as sh!t.

Imped 11-28-2012 02:14 PM

I just spent 9 months performing surgery on my rig, pushing the axle back being the big part of it.....and I've got just a wee bit of experience working under rigs.

First thing's first--you're taking 4wp's word and aren't even attempting to find proof. I wouldn't let 4wp change my oil, let alone give a higher-level diagnosis like that. If you can't even determine something relatively simple like that on your own, what makes you think you can perform all of that work in a weekend?

Get a HP30 out of an XJ and throw it in. Don't forget gears.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:44 AM.