Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   JK General Discussion Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/)
-   -   Sell 4 dr truck to get 4 dr Jeep - Yea or Nay? (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/sell-4-dr-truck-to-get-4-dr-jeep-yea-or-nay-237532.html)

MAG00 04-24-2013 04:34 PM

Sell 4 dr truck to get 4 dr Jeep - Yea or Nay?
 
I currently have a 2011 Chevy Silverado Z71 4 door truck with 50,000 miles. It has been a really good truck thus far. But the Jeep bug is geeting to me. I found a 2012 4 door Jeep with 15,000 miles that I could get into for the same payment I have now and only add 6 months to the loan duration (26 months left on truck and go to 32 months on the jeep to keep same payment). I am really having a hard time making the decision. So I thought I would get some thoughts/opinions. Here is some background info.

- I am married and have 3 kids
- We do own a small utility trailer
- We do not have any heavy equipment, travel trailer or boats to haul.
- We do have a 2012 Chevy Suburban for long trips and if we were to ever get a travel trailer or boat.
- Typically I don't haul alot of stuff in the bed of my truck. It has a bed cover so I can't haul real tall things anyways.
- Other than an occasional trip that we might take in my truck over the suburban, the only time I have alot of stuff in the bed is during hunting season when I throw alot of my gear in there and leave it since I have the lockable/weatherproof bed cover.

So what say you....sell the truck and get the jeep or keep what I got for now? Biggest hang up for me is extending my loan by 6 months. However, I would be getting a 1 year newer and less miles vehicle.

Thanks.

panthermark 04-24-2013 04:42 PM

This is a Wrangler website....so the obvious answer is...

"idiot, get back in there at once and sell, sellllll"

http://i2.ytimg.com/i/AegoxDe_IKEp74...jpg?v=4fc532bd

:D:thumb:

SuperTJ 04-24-2013 04:42 PM

Can't take doors off a silverado, can't take the top off a silverado.
Just saying, I had a 2500 silverado and other trucks. I love the jeep. I can't seem to find a cure for the jeep bug. There is a lot of room in the 2012 jeep.

Y-Guy 04-24-2013 05:00 PM

I traded in a great 2007 F-150 Lariat, pretty well loaded and I'm very happy I did it. I do have a boat, we're selling our ATVs and trailer and I'm getting small utility trailer, first made sure I could tow everything I needed to. I don't regret the trade at all, in fact I'd say that I enjoy driving again. The F-150 was great, but it's a truck, it was big, poor MPG and overkill 90% of the time. Jeep doesn't get great MPG but better then my truck did and it's 110% more fun to drive.

Just after we bought the Jeep we had 5 of us in, 2 adults and 3 teens - I'm going to modify the rear seat to lean back a bit, but reality is that we don't take my two boys and his GF that often anyway.

You're call but I can say I've been very happy with the trade.

Dragonscape 04-24-2013 05:01 PM

with just 26 months; I would suggest that you wait, scrape, save and plan for the 2015/16 Wrangler. I have a Ford F250 4dr 4x4 when the Jeep bug bit, managed to do above and got the 2010 JK....was worth the wait cause now I have both,,, the fun two door JK and a big truck.

jkjeeper06 04-24-2013 05:04 PM

My dad was in the same boat as you. He had a z71 crew cab. He loved it but it was a little too big if you know what I mean. It was too long for our garages and he didnt use the bed as much as he imagined. For skiing, his boots would get cold in the bed which wasnt very comfortable to put them on. Also the dog can't ride in the bed as it didnt have a cap. He ended up trading for a 2014 grand Cherokee(I couldn't convince him of diesel). He doesn't regret it at all. Like you he has a utility trailer and I gave him an extra hitch cargo basket I had.

I'd test drive the wrangler. If you like it you should definitely get it. You can't legally have more fun in any other vehicle. Between taking the doors and top off and taking it in the woods they are a blast to own

legitposter 04-24-2013 05:04 PM

You clearly want the wrangler and have thought this out. Just get the wrangler. There will be pro's and con's but you'll enjoy it which is what's important.

Maybe the wrangler won't be a good choice in the long run, maybe you'll need a truck afterall. Who knows? You can deal with that if the time comes. For now, just get the wrangler and smile.

jkjeeper06 04-24-2013 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by legitposter (Post 3678197)
Maybe the wrangler won't be a good choice in the long run, maybe you'll need a truck afterall. Who knows? You can deal with that if the time comes

And with a super high resale value it's a pretty safe investment as far as cars go

traitor08 04-24-2013 05:11 PM

I would trade. The 4dr jeep has a lot going for it.

Milspec1 04-24-2013 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MAG00 (Post 3678082)
I currently have a 2011 Chevy Silverado Z71 4 door truck with 50,000 miles. It has been a really good truck thus far. But the Jeep bug is geeting to me. I found a 2012 4 door Jeep with 15,000 miles that I could get into for the same payment I have now and only add 6 months to the loan duration (26 months left on truck and go to 32 months on the jeep to keep same payment). I am really having a hard time making the decision. So I thought I would get some thoughts/opinions. Here is some background info.

- I am married and have 3 kids
- We do own a small utility trailer
- We do not have any heavy equipment, travel trailer or boats to haul.
- We do have a 2012 Chevy Suburban for long trips and if we were to ever get a travel trailer or boat.
- Typically I don't haul alot of stuff in the bed of my truck. It has a bed cover so I can't haul real tall things anyways.
- Other than an occasional trip that we might take in my truck over the suburban, the only time I have alot of stuff in the bed is during hunting season when I throw alot of my gear in there and leave it since I have the lockable/weatherproof bed cover.

So what say you....sell the truck and get the jeep or keep what I got for now? Biggest hang up for me is extending my loan by 6 months. However, I would be getting a 1 year newer and less miles vehicle.

Thanks.

If you're looking at a 2012 with a Pentastar, you may want to listen for a ticking sound coming from the engine bay.

http://www.wranglerforum.com/showthr...errerid=143633

HK_Runner 04-24-2013 05:16 PM

Make sure you're getting a good trade-in and price, and they are not constantly talking about the trade difference and payments...tried and true car salesman tricks.

Anyway, if you're offroading, of course. If not, it is a tough call and really depends on you. I assume you have driven it and like it a lot. Many here are fanatical fans. While I like my Jeep, I would not have one if I did not go offroad as much as I do. However, I have a 2-door, and bought it for exploring. The 4-door is more practical and comfortable,

Senior Chief 04-24-2013 05:17 PM

I live in a community here in Colorado that's just a petri dish for young families and kiddos. It seems like I see a new JKU every day....

HK_Runner 04-24-2013 05:20 PM

Do you live in Highlands Ranch? :)

landi jeep 04-24-2013 05:24 PM

i think you have the decision made in your head but need a rationalization to go for the jeep. Everyone has their needs and desires. It seems like you have everything you "need" but desire the wrangler. Id say go for it, because the JKU will still suffice as far as hauling the kids and possibly hunting equipment. pick up (no pun intended) an older pick up as a beater for hunting season and towing around town.

Dusthol 04-24-2013 05:35 PM

I had a f250. Traded for my jeep and haven't looked back. I say go for it. U have the family vehicle.

Dynogyno 04-24-2013 06:52 PM

I traded my 2010 GMC Denali pick up, fully loaded for a 2012 rubicon unlimited and have not regretted it. It is roomy, comfortable and easier to park. Believe it or not, I get almost the same amount of lumber and other building supplies in the back with an extra foot lengthwise. Mattresses are problematic.

Eorozco 04-24-2013 06:55 PM

Do it!!!!

mike1158 04-24-2013 07:05 PM

i you have a Suburban and a trialer, well then...
go ahead....you know you want to
i have an Avalanche...when i got my Jeep, i kept it. its got 175,000 miles on it but its in perfect condition..the thing was that it's not worth anything to anyone..EXCEPT ME.. if i traded it i woulda got about $5000. no thanks i'll keep it for the bed and the fact thats its a great truck.
If a Jeep were gonna be my ONLY vehicle i might not have got one...or at least not a 2 door.. but with the Avalanche AND my wife's Grand Cherokee Limted in the driveway, i went for it.
I actually bought a 2 door to use as a work vehicle..so 90% of the time it's juts me... i manage site work for a developer...so far its working out really nice.. I LOVE IT

HAFICON 04-24-2013 07:28 PM

traded my 2008 Speedway Blue Tacoma 4dr TRD Edition, for my 2012 Jeep wrangler 4dr... never been Happier...

Senior Chief 04-24-2013 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HK_Runner (Post 3678254)
Do you live in Highlands Ranch? :)

Stapleton. Highlands Ranch is another petri dish....:D

Abnormal-JK 04-24-2013 07:35 PM

Is this a trick question?

msubrave 04-24-2013 07:39 PM

I had a '95 pathfinder, then '02 4runner, then '11 f150. I hated the truck and now i have a '12 jku and i don't plan to ever buy another truck.

i82much 04-24-2013 07:43 PM

21 Attachment(s)
The two reasons to keep the truck would be (1) the bed and (2) the towing capacity. With a Suburban and a utility trailer, there is absolutely no reason to keep the truck.

In fact, with the resale on these Wranglers being so high and the ridiculously low interest rates these days, I would venture to say it is something close to cost-neutral for you to trade your truck in on a Jeep. Really. Do the math, consider resale, interest rates, insurance, gas cost, maintenance, all of it.

fredbama 04-24-2013 08:16 PM

I also traded a 2009 F150 super crew. Traded for my 2 door sport. I have only used my utility trailer once in a year and a half. Did not miss or use the bed near as much as I thought. Sure spur of the moment things may require a trip home to get the trailer but that is just more seat time in the Jeep. Win win I think.

Txrdstr 04-24-2013 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MAG00 (Post 3678082)
I currently have a 2011 Chevy Silverado Z71 4 door truck with 50,000 miles. It has been a really good truck thus far. But the Jeep bug is geeting to me. I found a 2012 4 door Jeep with 15,000 miles that I could get into for the same payment I have now and only add 6 months to the loan duration (26 months left on truck and go to 32 months on the jeep to keep same payment). I am really having a hard time making the decision. So I thought I would get some thoughts/opinions. Here is some background info.

- I am married and have 3 kids
- We do own a small utility trailer
- We do not have any heavy equipment, travel trailer or boats to haul.
- We do have a 2012 Chevy Suburban for long trips and if we were to ever get a travel trailer or boat.
- Typically I don't haul alot of stuff in the bed of my truck. It has a bed cover so I can't haul real tall things anyways.
- Other than an occasional trip that we might take in my truck over the suburban, the only time I have alot of stuff in the bed is during hunting season when I throw alot of my gear in there and leave it since I have the lockable/weatherproof bed cover.

So what say you....sell the truck and get the jeep or keep what I got for now? Biggest hang up for me is extending my loan by 6 months. However, I would be getting a 1 year newer and less miles vehicle.

Thanks.

Man if it is what you want go for it, I did both for a while, the truck had a bedcover and was never used to haul much and after buying the jeep, it just sat since he jeep is actually fun. Sold it and have not missed it yet in 6 months.

dalearyous 04-24-2013 08:51 PM

we are all a little biased here ...

eightshb 04-24-2013 09:01 PM

Get the jeep you will not regret it what's the big deal you have a Burby

ohioviper 04-24-2013 09:14 PM

I bet you can get almost the same payment on a brand new 2013. Try another dealer and see what you can do. Have them give you an appraisal on your trade before you try to deal on the Jeep. Then go for the Tread lightly discount or offer them 1 or 2% below invoice. Dont try to deal based on monthly payment.Get the trade in value up front and go from there.

ilikeguns 04-24-2013 09:33 PM

in a similar story... "i asked my crack dealer if I should go into rehab..."

SoCaljeep08 04-24-2013 09:41 PM

Here's the deal, the jeep is going to lack the power and Is much less comfortable for passengers. What you will find though is your gonna love your jeep, style, convertible, off road fun for family camping trips. Everything about the jeep us great including FunTo Drive.... Go for the jeep bud!!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:41 AM.