Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   JK General Discussion Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/)
-   -   Spare Wheel Bike rack? Yakima or Thule (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f274/spare-wheel-bike-rack-yakima-or-thule-88657.html)

AEsco48 04-10-2011 01:03 AM

Spare Wheel Bike rack? Yakima or Thule
 
Which is the better and more stable bike rack for the spare wheel on a 2011 Wrangler Unlimited with the factory spare.

The Thule 963XTR or the Yakima SpareTime?

The 963 is wider and would appear to be more stable, but looking for experiences advise.

THule
http://www.quadratec.com/Assets/Imag.../147967-lg.jpg

Yak
http://www.rack-it.com/img/d_1362.jpg


Thx.

Ape 04-10-2011 08:09 AM

Personally, not a fan of either due to the stability. Will you be using often? If so, I'd seriously consider going with a hitch mount.

AEsco48 04-10-2011 08:20 AM

Hmm... Yea the idea is to get a hitch if I get a motorcycle... thing is i am living in Cairo Egypt and its not easy to get the hitch or the motorcycle... If i am able to get the motorcycle I will bring the hitch over via sea freight with another shipment.

I think for now ill get a spare tire mounted one that can be brought on an airplane as luggage.

Between the two which is "more" stable.... :)

Thx

jkjeeper06 04-10-2011 09:41 AM

I have the Thule on my jeep. I love it! It only holds 2 bikes tho which in a way is good cuz it won't torque your tailgate. I also put the Thule ski rack on top of the Thule rack in the winter. I've had this set up running year around for 2 years and 0 complaints one thing to caution you about tho is don't open the tailgate door when bikes are on the back. This will put all the weight on the door hinges. I would delfinately get this rack if you want a tailgate rack. If you do go for a hitch one, be sure to get one that swings away sideways. They are a little more expensive but itll allow you to use the tailgate with the rack on

nickandsusan 04-10-2011 10:47 AM

I have the Yakima on my Rubicon with 32" stock tires and I can't keep the rack from moving. Can't crank the rack down any harder on to the tire and I have used all the adapters. It is constantly moving and when not hauling bikes it still moves around back there and makes an annoying noise I can hear while driving.

Probo 04-10-2011 10:59 AM

Get a hidden hitch... And bike rack for hitch.... Only way to go....

RB-10rubicon 04-10-2011 04:35 PM

Thule works great IMO the sweeds make some nice stuff .depending on your bike you might need the bar that allows girl bikes to sit straite .it attaches under the seat and handle bar easy to remove i think they are like thirty bucks.my bikes frame is thick and narrow so i use the bar to make it fit

mountainluv 04-11-2011 12:46 PM

I have the Yakima rack as well...it works well with one or two bikes on there...just be aware that the cradles where the bikes sit scratch the shizz out of your frames, i added some extra rubber and that eliviated the problem! Also the " security wire" that comes with it is useless as we discovered when someone cut right through it and stole our brand new kona hardtails!! maybe we shoulda went with the Thule......

Dianeakamommy 04-11-2011 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by [LEFT
Probo[/LEFT];1169401]Get a hidden hitch... And bike rack for hitch.... Only way to go....


Which one would you recommend? I need one and this makes the most sense.

nickandsusan 04-11-2011 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountainluv (Post 1171668)
I have the Yakima rack as well...it works well with one or two bikes on there...just be aware that the cradles where the bikes sit scratch the shizz out of your frames, i added some extra rubber and that eliviated the problem! Also the " security wire" that comes with it is useless as we discovered when someone cut right through it and stole our brand new kona hardtails!! maybe we shoulda went with the Thule......


Dang, Kona hardtails gone..sux!!

Which tire are you mounting the rack to? Any wobble with the rack at all?

jk'n 04-11-2011 02:17 PM

I have the Thule 2" hitch mount swing type rack that holds 4 bikes and it performs very well. I would consider it the Cadillac of bike racks. If I had to go with a spare mount, I would stay with the Thule. For roof rack, I have a congo cage with Yakima attachment clamps and use that for skis and kayaks. The choice there has to do with the Yakima bars being round and Thule being square. For kayaks, being able to tilt the mounts in on the round bars to match the hull of the boat makes all the difference for not stressing the hull at one point. I would still stay with this choice. So, Yakima bars up top, Thule rack on the back.

Also, I don't care which rack system you get to put bicycles on, putting more than one bike on it will cause rubbing between the bikes and paint damage. If you are going to transport your bikes on a rack that brings them close together, get used to paint damage. I don't ride the paint on the bike, I ride the bike so the damage to the paint I don't care about. Also, I put the bikes in a covered trailer but tying them down results in the same type of damage to the paint. I've gotten used to it. When the bikes were new, I used to fret over it. The added benefit to the paint damage is that it makes their theft appeal a little less. <my glass is always half full>

jk'n 04-11-2011 02:21 PM

If you want to get a bike rack that doesn't damage the paint on the bike, try the roof mount channel type rack that has the bike standing up and not touching anything else, especially another bike. That is if you are anal about scratches to the paint job on the bike.

Robd225 04-11-2011 02:48 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Neither , Walmart sells a 5 bike rack made by Allen for $99 with free site to store shipping, it's well built and sturdy.
This rack does't wobble or does it need a hitch extender.

jk'n 04-11-2011 02:54 PM

With the bike rack experience I've had, four adult bikes, not light weight ones...I wouldn't trust my bikes on that rack. The Thule is built like a brick you know what house and priced like one too. I trust 4 adult heavy bikes on it that they will not collapse it. Five on that one? I wouldn't trust it.

Seajuice 04-11-2011 06:01 PM

Yakima works great for me. Plus you have the added bottle openers for beers after the ride!

jk'n 04-12-2011 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seajuice (Post 1172352)
Yakima works great for me. Plus you have the added bottle openers for beers after the ride!

Now the bottle openers could close the deal for a lot of jeepers! :D

You can't go wrong with either Yakima or Thule. They both make great products with very little differences....like round vs square bars on roof racks. When considering the application, round could be better...or square. Round was better for me.

bobafetske 12-24-2011 09:35 PM

so the Thule one? Will they both fit Jeeps with 35's? I have a 2010 2-door Rubicon hard top with stock wheels and tires. The plan is to move up to 35's eventually (within the next 6 months) and i'd like to be able to use the rack still once i upgrade. The Thule looks much more stable. But the Yakima looks clean. I just ned to know which will be best with an oversized tire. Thank you so much

greenjeepgurl87 12-24-2011 09:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robd225
Neither , Walmart sells a 5 bike rack made by Allen for $99 with free site to store shipping, it's well built and sturdy.
This rack does't wobble or does it need a hitch extender.

This is what I have to. I love it. :thumb:

carrotzilla 12-24-2011 10:06 PM

Thule is better quality IMO than Yakima but I've had both for kayak, bikes and paddleboard racks. Currently using a hitch mounted Yakima and would not suggest tire mounted if you're doing any off-roading w/mountain bikes hanging out the back.

bobafetske 12-24-2011 10:21 PM

i dont plan on doing any off-roading with the bikes. if i off road i will take the bike off. I just am curious if eitehr will fit an oversized tire. I've read that the Yakima one coumes with different length mounts to fit larger tires (12.5 is the largest i saw) i've heard the Thule one only fits stock size. Is this true? My jeep has stock wheels and tires now but not for long and i'd ratgehr be able to use the rack for a long time. Help!!!

theotis 12-24-2011 10:27 PM

I have the Thule, I like it alot, but I don't think it will go bigger than stock 32 tires.

oncewas 12-24-2011 10:51 PM

We had a Thule 963XTR when we had a FJ and it worked very well. We are planning to get another very soon for our Wrangler. You may need to purchase a longer carriage bolt if I remember correctly but that's no big thing.

hdrider 12-25-2011 08:44 AM

I opted for the Yakima Spare Time. I don't use it a bunch but am happy with it when I do.
The pictures are from when it was on my 08. I have not installed it on my 12 yet but I'm running the same rear bumper and tires so I see no problem.
http://i96.photobucket.com/albums/l1...h_IMG_1886.jpg
http://i96.photobucket.com/albums/l1...h_IMG_1885.jpg
http://i96.photobucket.com/albums/l1...h_IMG_1881.jpg

Wmpj08 04-10-2013 09:25 PM

What is the biggest size tire you can have with the thule rack? And with the Yakima?

mcdull 04-11-2013 02:41 AM

I got the Thule spare tire bike rack because it allows adding an attachment to turn it into ski/snowboard rack. Got them used so about half of retail.
Sadly too busy last season, so haven't tried them yet.

TX Sasquatch 04-11-2013 07:58 AM

I use my bike rack very frequently. Several times a week when the weather permits. I also use the tailgate area of my jeep as it is my main secured storage spot since I have a soft top, 2 door, and tuffy security trunk. So, a hitch rack was not an option since my bike rack is on nearly 100% of the time, and I require easy access to the tailgate area.

I went with the Yakima spare time and it is great. It even fits with my wheel/tire combo (15" MB 72 wheels, Goodyear Duratrack 33x12.5R15).

I was concerned about the weight on the tailgate so I did get an aftermarket bumper/tire carrier (Ace) but that was part of my plan from the get go. I feel that the whole setup is very secure, reliable, and meets my needs.

Jekyll 04-11-2013 09:05 AM

I would go with a hitch rack that holds the bike by the wheel. Both Thule and Yakima make one and if you really want to spend money there is kuat. The hitch mount gives you more options for different bikes and you never have to worry about a bike or some one else's bike fitting on. I have a mountain bike that can't fit on a rack that secures via the top tube so that is a factor for me also.

sonofmilkman2 04-11-2013 01:56 PM

A hitch-mounted Kuat rack is the way to go, if money isn't an object. I have the Yakima Spare Time rack on my Jeep, though, and haven't had a problem with it yet.

speedguy 04-11-2013 02:24 PM

I use a Yakima Holdup hitch-mounted bike carrier and I have a 35x12.5 inch spare tire mounted. I use a 6 inch hitch extension to provide enough clearance between the spare tire and the bike rack. I also use the Yakima Plus 2 (2+) adapter which adds capacity for 2 additional bikes. This Yakima is awesome and I have been using it weekly for 3+ years now.

JOCJK 04-11-2013 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by speedguy (Post 3624192)
I use a Yakima Holdup hitch-mounted bike carrier and I have a 35x12.5 inch spare tire mounted. I use a 6 inch hitch extension to provide enough clearance between the spare tire and the bike rack. I also use the Yakima Plus 2 (2+) adapter which adds capacity for 2 additional bikes. This Yakima is awesome and I have been using it weekly for 3+ years now.

Does that Holdup rack with the extension allow you to open the tailgate when folded down without the bikes? I can't seem to find one that I can leave on the jeep and still get access to the back. Its a giant pain in the ass to have to take the thing off all the time to get at gear. Any help would be appreciated!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:47 PM.