Jeep Wrangler Forum

Jeep Wrangler Forum (http://www.wranglerforum.com/)
-   Tires & Wheels (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f27/)
-   -   Sahara 18" vs. Rubicon 17" (http://www.wranglerforum.com/f27/sahara-18-vs-rubicon-17-a-93192.html)

GPappy 05-10-2011 08:44 PM

Sahara 18" vs. Rubicon 17"
 
I am looking for some wheels and tires for my YJ and haven't had much luck finding anything used that would make sense buying. About ready to just get some Soft 8's and some cheaper new tires.

Then I started running across some good deals on used Sahara's and Rubicon tires and wheels. I can get a set of 5 Saharas with Duelers for $400 or a set of 5 Rubicons with BFG MT's for $600. Each have about 10K miles on them. I would rather have the BFG but the Duelers would work for most of what I would be using them for.

I realize that both would require adapters but I am putting a Ford 8.8 in and thought that if I could get a larger adapter in the back than in the front it would make up for the axle being 5/8" shorter on each side.

I would prefer a 33 or 34 by 12.5 tire and both of these tires are 32x10. I was thinking that I could run these until they were wore down and then buy bigger tires.

Here are the questions:

Thoughts on Rubicons vs Shaharas? 18 vs 17 for performance/look.

Why in the world are 18 inch tires so much more than 17 inch tires??? It would seem like less rubber would be needed to make the same tire but the 18s are more expensive.

sdwndr 05-18-2011 02:55 PM

Personally, I think the 18" wheels are just too big and blingy-looking. I'd go with the Rubicons. I have no idea why tires get more expensive for the bigger wheels. It's weird.

Mikekaz1 05-18-2011 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GPappy
I am looking for some wheels and tires for my YJ and haven't had much luck finding anything used that would make sense buying. About ready to just get some Soft 8's and some cheaper new tires.

Then I started running across some good deals on used Sahara's and Rubicon tires and wheels. I can get a set of 5 Saharas with Duelers for $400 or a set of 5 Rubicons with BFG MT's for $600. Each have about 10K miles on them. I would rather have the BFG but the Duelers would work for most of what I would be using them for.

I realize that both would require adapters but I am putting a Ford 8.8 in and thought that if I could get a larger adapter in the back than in the front it would make up for the axle being 5/8" shorter on each side.

I would prefer a 33 or 34 by 12.5 tire and both of these tires are 32x10. I was thinking that I could run these until they were wore down and then buy bigger tires.

Here are the questions:

Thoughts on Rubicons vs Shaharas? 18 vs 17 for performance/look.

Why in the world are 18 inch tires so much more than 17 inch tires??? It would seem like less rubber would be needed to make the same tire but the 18s are more expensive.

Double on the expensiveness of a bigger rimed tire. But I think 18" is pushing it with offroadability. I have the 16"rubicon rims from the tjs and I like the look not too big not too small in relation to the rubber. I'd go 17" in your case tho

InfernoGirl 05-18-2011 03:13 PM

x3

GPappy 05-19-2011 08:13 AM

Thanks all for the input. I did some more research and decided to stick with 15" rims. I bought some new Soft 8's from Summit and some 35x12.5x15 BFGoodrich Mud Terrain KM2s from Discount tire. Never could get anyone to tell me for sure why the tires for larger diameter rims cost more but a friend had an idea that makes sense. If you look at the load rating on most 17 and 18 inch wheels they are D or E which is a bit stiff for a Jeep.

BFGoodrich Mud Terrain KM2

35x12.5x15 Load Range C - $190
315-75R17 Load Range D - $275 (these are close in size)

Then only C range I could find in 17s was the 25575R17 at $194 but that was smaller than I wanted.


So for just a tad over $1000 mounted and spun balanced for new tires and rims I decided to stay with the 15". I do have 5" of spring lift and a 3" body lift so the 35's should work fine. I don't care for that much body lift so I after I get things mounted and tested I will reduce that as much as possible.

InfernoGirl 05-19-2011 08:44 AM

:) Excellent choice!

Mikekaz1 05-19-2011 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GPappy
Thanks all for the input. I did some more research and decided to stick with 15" rims. I bought some new Soft 8's from Summit and some 35x12.5x15 BFGoodrich Mud Terrain KM2s from Discount tire. Never could get anyone to tell me for sure why the tires for larger diameter rims cost more but a friend had an idea that makes sense. If you look at the load rating on most 17 and 18 inch wheels they are D or E which is a bit stiff for a Jeep.

BFGoodrich Mud Terrain KM2

35x12.5x15 Load Range C - $190
315-75R17 Load Range D - $275 (these are close in size)

Then only C range I could find in 17s was the 25575R17 at $194 but that was smaller than I wanted.

So for just a tad over $1000 mounted and spun balanced for new tires and rims I decided to stay with the 15". I do have 5" of spring lift and a 3" body lift so the 35's should work fine. I don't care for that much body lift so I after I get things mounted and tested I will reduce that as much as possible.

Hmm yeah my 16" are load E I think. Rated for around 3050lbs per tire


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:45 AM.