OK, the linked thread is insightful. I still don't want MTs or (real) 35s, but I saw options for 34x10s and even the 280 80/75 R17s seem really nice.It's all good.
That size isn't really a standard size for Jeep tires but the slightly smaller 255/80-17 is, and it is a nice size. A little taller than what you have.
Another great option for pizza cutter tires is either the Kenda or Goodyear MT in a 35x10.5-17 / 280/80-17. A little wider than what you have, but still a narrow for its height tire.
Both actually measure out at either a bit OVER 34", or a bit UNDER 34"; both good options. The 34x10s are effing' $350 each:jawdrop: