I would say if you want to do a lot more hard core wheeling go for the winch. I've never had to use mine, and experience dictates that you always use them on someone else. But, it is good insurance. If your existing top is in good shape, go for the winch and just watch the ads until you find one close enough to get. But, if you're in need of a top, don't leave yourself out in the cold. Like amerijeep said, if it's to prevent theft, don't worry too much, if they want it they'll get it anyway. Don't leave valuables in a jeep, or put them in a tuffy box.