I've heard really good things about Rhinoliner and Line-x, but you can expect paying a bit more with that than if you went with Herculiner. I've had my Herc in the tub for a while now and can't complain.Yeah most people do Herculiner or Rhinoliner, or if you want to get it done professionally Line-X is good. Or you could buy a Raptor kit and DIY which I have heard good things about. I Herculined mine after BamianYJ told me about his and I love it. It looks great and is really rugged.