I have the Smittybilt XRC Rock Sliders on my Jeep, will I replace them with something better when the time comes, yes. Have they worked well for the time that I've had them, yes. I slid into a rock on my passengers side last year and dented in the tube but it held up really well and kept the rock off my tub. Would definitely recommend getting something with a tube like what you're looking at, it served its purpose for me. One thing to consider is if you have a dog, they can get caught up in the bar when trying to get in your Jeep and hurt themselves.