I've gotten mixed messages there as well.
These quote are from another forum. :facepalm:
I know my TJ on 31's and 3:73's is bearable on the highway, (which I drive up to 500 miles/week for work) Top and doors off and forget 5th gear. When I had 3:07s 5th gear was down hill.
I can pull my boat on the highway and not have much issse in fifth. (Boat and gear are only about 800lbs)
Yeah, the whole gearing thing is really subjective. I try to tell peeps, hit 2500 rpms on a JK, and you're good to go. Nevertheless, there are folks on here running 35's on 3.21 gears, and say they're happy.
There are a lot of variables. If you drive in a city, and rarely hit the freeway, you might not really notice the power loss. A manual will do better than an auto. Live where it's flat? Much less of an issue. Weight and tire width...all factor into the end result.
As I mentioned, I've got a '12 JKU (manual) with 35's and 3.73 gears. I live in Wisconsin. Pretty flat. Rarely use 6th gear on the freeway, and generally
can't on hills or in a strong wind, or when trying to pass, without bleeding speed like I'm gutshot. I drove to the East Coast recently, and going through the PA mountains there were even a few times I couldn't get outta 4th. I've added a fair amount of weight to my Jeep with bumpers and other mods, but some of that is offset by the fact that I run a soft top year-round.
With my current setup, pulling an 800-lb boat would be miserable, I suspect.
Here's a thread from a member named Pieface that'll give you a better idea of what I'm talking about, rpm and gear-wise. First page deals with his 2012; second goes into the 3.8L engines. Lots of info there, regardless of your Jeep's engine. If you can parse the bs from the gold, should give you a pretty solid foundation of knowledge to make a decision on what, if anything, you wanna do, in terms of gearing.
Want 35s dont want to REGEAR ??