Jeep Wrangler Forum banner
  • Hey everyone! Enter your ride HERE to be a part of JUNE's Ride of the Month Challenge!

1 - 20 of 43 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
392 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This is for their 50" led light bar: Why rigid when you can spend 1/3 on lets say lifetime leds? Just curious. I have rigid duallys but can't wrap my head around $1500 for one light when you can buy a similar light for $500
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
784 Posts
Honestly asking this question is the same as a Chinese winch owner asking a warn winch owner "why pay more for a Warn?"

You think the rigids are big bucks, you should check out Baja designs setups.
 

·
Jeeper
Joined
·
1,307 Posts
Is it the same? I'm not sure... but Rigid was the first to market and they had no competition so they could charge whatever they wanted as long as people paid. Now there are a number of competitors coming to market with a $500 price point for the 50". Is the quality better or worse? We may need more time to tell... but honestly if one takes their rig off-road and beat it to hell all the time, buying the most expensive mods may not make sense for all aspects of their Jeep.

On a side note, I bought an Engo winch and I LOVE mine. It unspools easy and have worked great at saving some butts. IMHO, Engo was the true winner of that winch competition, but Warn did sponsor it, so ultimately they "won" because they paid to win.

In this case, get what works for you. Expensive stuff do break as well... and if your $500 LED breaks, you can test out what customer service is really like for these companies or maybe just buy up to 2 more 50" LED's for the price of that Rigid.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
392 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Is it the same? I'm not sure... but Rigid was the first to market and they had no competition so they could charge whatever they wanted as long as people paid. Now there are a number of competitors coming to market with a $500 price point for the 50". Is the quality better or worse? We may need more time to tell... but honestly if one takes their rig off-road and beat it to hell all the time, buying the most expensive mods may not make sense for all aspects of their Jeep.

On a side note, I bought an Engo winch and I LOVE mine. It unspools easy and have worked great at saving some butts. IMHO, Engo was the true winner of that winch competition, but Warn did sponsor it, so ultimately they "won" because they paid to win.

In this case, get what works for you. Expensive stuff do break as well... and if your $500 LED breaks, you can test out what customer service is really like for these companies or maybe just buy up to 2 more 50" LED's for the price of that Rigid.
That is my thought process. Lifetime led claims to have a lifetime warranty so you should be covered there.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
392 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Honestly asking this question is the same as a Chinese winch owner asking a warn winch owner "why pay more for a Warn?"

You think the rigids are big bucks, you should check out Baja designs setups.
While I understand your viewpoint. Lights are very different then winches. Lots of things can go wrong with winches because of mechanical and electrical parts. A light is a light. Why wouldn't it turn on when I flip the switch?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
221 Posts
From your response in the prior thread:

So why would anybody pay 1k more just to use 5.4 amps less? Am I missing something? Does the 6 amps less give you any advantage?

14.4A vs. 20A is a significant difference if you take into account wire standards and derating. Google search wire tolerances at different ampacities vs. heat. Heat will degrade the ampacity of a wire and ultimately cause it to fail. Therefore if you're making your own harness you have to take that into account.

Another factor is switching, the switches are rated at a certain ampacity also and one would have to take that into account also. Check this switch out: Rugged Ridge 17235.04 - Rugged Ridge 2 Position Rocker Switch - Quadratec
Manufacturer states 20A rating, but if you have a load that is going to in fact pull 20A that switch will get mighty hot after an extended period of use and probably fail.

As far as fusing just properly size the fuses and you'll be fine...

And to back up my claims... here is Rigid's wiring harness:

http://www.rigidindustries.com/installation-accessories/40192

And here is Lifetime's harness:

Switch Kit

But does current draw matter? Nah, but if you're stuck with a dead engine and you're running off of battery power that's a whole new ball of wax! :punk:

Sorry, you asked for pros and cons, and I'm bored at work.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,714 Posts
Honestly asking this question is the same as a Chinese winch owner asking a warn winch owner "why pay more for a Warn?"

You think the rigids are big bucks, you should check out Baja designs setups.
Rigid's components (mechanical and electrical) are Chinese. They are not "made in America", they are assembled in America. Biiig difference. You can buy the exact same light elsewhere for a fraction of the cost, with the same quality.
 

·
Jeeper
Joined
·
1,307 Posts
Rigid's components (mechanical and electrical) are Chinese. They are not "made in America", they are assembled in America. Biiig difference. You can buy the exact same light elsewhere for a fraction of the cost, with the same quality.
BOOM.

thats an answer that stopped me in my tracks.

My truck wears engo lights, and I LOVE them. They are just as tough. and boy do they turn night into day.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,410 Posts
It's all about Marketing.

Up until now, I've never heard of Lifetime LED's. Rigid, yes, they're everywhere.

I for one, have Drank the Kool-Aid and bought a Pair of Rigid D2's. Are they Bright? HELL NO!! They are nowhere NEAR the Brightness that they Look in the Pictures.

I then Bought the Baja Designs Squadrons. Are they Bright? HELL YES!! As Bright, maybe a Touch Brighter than HID.

1 Baja Squadron still Outshines TWO Dually D2's, BY FAR. It's not even Fair.

So where does my Money go now? To Baja Designs, and the China Man who I bought my 20" LED Bar from.

IMO, Rigid is WAY Overhyped and Overpriced for what you get. Save Money and Buy from the China Man or Spend a lil more and get Baja Designs and REALLY get what you Pay for.

Rant over. :)
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,101 Posts
Rigid's components (mechanical and electrical) are Chinese. They are not "made in America", they are assembled in America. Biiig difference. You can buy the exact same light elsewhere for a fraction of the cost, with the same quality.
Correct. Aurora is the company that builds lights with the exact same components. I have a suspicion that Rigid buys their circutboards from Aurora since Aurora actually builds their own circuitry.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
877 Posts
I have the rigid 20" bar on my bumper. The fit and finish is top notch and every thing works well. Would I recommend it to someone looking for a light bar, probably not. My buddy has an eBay special 20" which he paid like 260 shipped and honest to God, I can't tell any difference between the 2. Except two to three times the cost. Maybe I need to mount it higher, don't know. But for the cost of the rigid, I expect to see way more than I do with it. One thing I can say though is rigids customer service is superb.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
392 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
20" bar on amazon/eBay for $150. 1 year warranty. Can't really beat that. Or lifetime led for $250 and lifetime warranty.


This is rigid industries lifetime warranty:


image-1892323417.jpg

This is lifetime led warranty:
"We will replace or repair your light if any of the LEDs fail or if there is any defect in the lights, for as long as you own the light.. As an added bonus, if you order a light and do not like it, you have 7 business days to return it for a full refund plus we will pay return shipping (must be in original packaging, in new condition). Email [email protected] with any questions you may have."

"Our warranty is what sets us apart from the rest. We believe that you are entitled to a great product, at a great price, without having to worry about it, ever. We have a LIFETIME warranty on the LEDs in our lights. No need to read fine print, or wonder what limited lifetime means."

I see no advantage of rigid. Overpriced and too much hype over them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,166 Posts
How long will that other company be around? I am looking for some offroad lights to mount on my bumper, so am starting to research lights.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Wow! These could be the lights for me. I love the LIFETIME warranty :dance:

Any members here with the 50" light bar yet that can give us a review?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
784 Posts
From a recent post straight from the correct lighting forum for this stuff on WF::

I own a pair of both the Rigid Dually D2's and the Aurora competition. I did some testing with them.

1- Is there a difference between the two? Yes, there absolutely is, which tells me, something must be different in regards to parts.

2- Is it enough to warrant the extra cost of the Rigids? Depends on what you are looking for.

3- Warranty is a big issue as well. 1 year for the Aurora's vs more or less a lifetime on the Rigids. Had one go out, and Rigid sent me a new one, 2 years later, no questions asked.

Personally, I will purchase Rigids from now on. PM me your email and I will send you some comparison pictures. ::


I personally look for deals. When I came across a Rigid 50" and 10" brand new in the box for less than 1/2 off on RDC from guys who ran out of cash on their builds, I grabbed em.. The savings combined with no tax for a proven setup, it was a yes for me.

Rigids proven themselves with their product. Race desert guys beat the hell out of em for a long time here on the west coast and I haven't heard complaints. That speaks volumes for me. Best way I can think of to put it. You want a proven setup now from someone in the industry and will be around later? Rigid. U want unknown on your dime, go with the knock offs. There will be plenty of guys that will tell you step up and go with a proven setup like Rigid or Baja Designs(myself included). There will be plenty of guys telling you to go with knock offs (cause they did and the other guys are crazy paying so much). Really your wallet is the decider and Im sure you know the answer already.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
151 Posts
Black Box Logistics

I'm really glad that someone else posted this thread! I've been very verbal in my support of Black Box Logistics every since I started using their products, and I've made a couple of posts on this forum. I have no doubt that Rigid Industries makes a fine product. That being said, I do work for a living, and I don't have endless amounts of cash to dump into mods (no matter how much I'd like to do so). I simply can't see spending that much money! My 5" RX LEDs were half the price of a pair of RI D2s! And I'm totally satisfied with their performance. Eventually I'll add some lighting to the rear of my rig, and once again I'll place my order through BBL:thumb:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
518 Posts
BOOM.

thats an answer that stopped me in my tracks.

My truck wears engo lights, and I LOVE them. They are just as tough. and boy do they turn night into day.
But for the same wattage (120W), they only put out 7200 lumens vs. the 9600 lumens of the Black Box lights. And the BB lights are 1/3 cheaper.

And this is the problem... I've never heard of many of these "off" brands before, but some of their specs are fantastic.

....

*edit*

Looked at the Lifetime LED lights... they're only 100W and they make 9000 lumens, and they cost the same as the BB lights. Now that's getting pretty darn efficient. Not quite as good as the Rigid lights, but good enough to make the massive cost difference worthwhile.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,101 Posts
From a recent post straight from the correct lighting forum for this stuff on WF::

I own a pair of both the Rigid Dually D2's and the Aurora competition. I did some testing with them.

1- Is there a difference between the two? Yes, there absolutely is, which tells me, something must be different in regards to parts.

2- Is it enough to warrant the extra cost of the Rigids? Depends on what you are looking for.

3- Warranty is a big issue as well. 1 year for the Aurora's vs more or less a lifetime on the Rigids. Had one go out, and Rigid sent me a new one, 2 years later, no questions asked.

Personally, I will purchase Rigids from now on. PM me your email and I will send you some comparison pictures. ::

I personally look for deals. When I came across a Rigid 50" and 10" brand new in the box for less than 1/2 off on RDC from guys who ran out of cash on their builds, I grabbed em.. The savings combined with no tax for a proven setup, it was a yes for me.

Rigids proven themselves with their product. Race desert guys beat the hell out of em for a long time here on the west coast and I haven't heard complaints. That speaks volumes for me. Best way I can think of to put it. You want a proven setup now from someone in the industry and will be around later? Rigid. U want unknown on your dime, go with the knock offs. There will be plenty of guys that will tell you step up and go with a proven setup like Rigid or Baja Designs(myself included). There will be plenty of guys telling you to go with knock offs (cause they did and the other guys are crazy paying so much). Really your wallet is the decider and Im sure you know the answer already.
You are misusing the word knockoff. Other companies build LED bars as well. They are not knockoffs. Saying they are is like saying Philips is the only company making flat screen tvs and everyone is like Samsung is making knockoffs. Furthermore, rigid doesn't produce their wiring, the polycarbonate, their screws, their circuit boards, the LEDs and the housings. They only have a patent on the optics which indeed provides probably a 10% at best better spread but at more than 2 or 3 times the price. I own rigid and aurora led units and quality wise there is no difference. Saying their is a difference is pure fallacy. Rigid spends a fortune on marketing and sponsoring teams so your example of "guys in the desert running them" is also skewed. They were the first to mass market their lights and introduce LED lights to the offroad community. Since then, hundreds of other companies are making quality LED bars and rigid can no longer ride their reputation to warrant their prices. If they don't move with the market they won't last. Btw, rigid and aurora both have excellent customer service. I needed some parts for my aurora bar, and they shipped me a bag of parts, just so that I have spares, for free within 5 days.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,101 Posts
But for the same wattage (120W), they only put out 7200 lumens vs. the 9600 lumens of the Black Box lights. And the BB lights are 1/3 cheaper.

And this is the problem... I've never heard of many of these "off" brands before, but some of their specs are fantastic.

....

*edit*

Looked at the Lifetime LED lights... they're only 100W and they make 9000 lumens, and they cost the same as the BB lights. Now that's getting pretty darn efficient. Not quite as good as the Rigid lights, but good enough to make the massive cost difference worthwhile.
Don't get hung up on lumens. It's an arbitrary number that means nothing, just like camera megapixels mean nothing. My $8000 SLR camera has 21.1 megapixels and the new Nokia cell phone has 42 megapixels. Which one do you think produces better photos? What's important is the throw, the spread, etc.
 
1 - 20 of 43 Posts
Top