Yes Smittybilt is often associated with many bad names, one of them Chittybilt, i won't sugar coat it. I've/had a few parts from them despite their reputation, mostly cause their price is attractive to me and the durability of said items have been good in my application, so i can trust what i've used and abused from them.
I had the Smitty MOD front bumper in my first Jeep, ran it for 3 years and change, beat the crap out of that bumper on the trail and it never failed on me, the paint didn't flake and it didn't rust. i paid $200 back in 2015 if i remember for the thing brand new (on sale). Because of that experience it was repeat in 2021 when i bought my 2nd JKU. Almost 3 years later and i haven't have a single damn issue with it. no flakes no rust, nothing, install was a stupid breeze, and i put the winch AFTER i mounted the bumper, which i also knew was going to work based on my 1st experience with it. The scratches i have put in the bumper when i hit rocks with it will rust if i don't cover them with paint, what steel bumper wouldn't ? i paid $399 in 2021. How can i hate on this? Lol. Granted I would never tell anybody this bumper is better than something like a LOD or ARB or JCR, no way, but i'd only say it works for me and didn't break the bank and i haven't experienced any issues. I would never get any of the Smitty rock sliders though, i wouldn't get their bumper carriers, i do have Winches from them, always had and they have never failed me, currently a 9500K in the Jeep and a 12k comp in my truck. I also have a shovel from them

, i also had their basic tire carrier twice now, almost 3 years in my first JK, and 1 year in my 2nd one, both times with 35's, no issues with anything, zero vibrations, now i have their hinge tire carrier one, 2 years with a 35 and not a single issue with it. Again, i'm not saying Smitty will be better than any of the stuff we get Made in USA but for the price, the few items i have from them, and i do use them in full, have performed without a single issue, fully functional and zero regrets here. If i had any issues with any of these items i'll be the first to vocalize them, I don't tend to sugar coat things.